Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label PF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PF. Show all posts

Monday, February 24, 2014

March PF Topic

Resolved: Single-gender classrooms would improve the quality of education in public schools.

Thursday, January 9, 2014

February PF Debate Topic

Resolved: The Supreme Court rightly decided that Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act violated the Constitution.

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Jan./Feb. Debate Topics

Lincoln-Douglas January/February Topic
Resolved: Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

Public Forum January Topic
Resolved: Development assistance should be prioritized over military aid in the Sahel region of Africa

Thursday, August 15, 2013

September 2013 PF Topic

Resolved: Unilateral military force by the United States is justified to prevent nuclear proliferation.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Sept. PF Topic possibilities

Oh, yes.  It's already starting...

NFL has now released the list of potential topics for 2013 Sept. Public Forum.  The topic area is nuclear proliferation.  Coaches will be voting for one of the following topics:

Resolved: Unilateral military force by the United States is justified to prevent nuclear proliferation.

Resolved: Proliferation of nuclear weapons is a greater threat to the United States than proliferation of biological and chemical weapons.

Thursday, May 2, 2013

Sunday, March 3, 2013

March PF - CON

Here's an article explaining how the health care mandate is:
1. Constitutional - The Supreme Court ruled that the penalty amounts to a tax and falls within the government's taxing powers.

2. Handles the "adverse selection process" - By requiring everyone to have health insurance it broadens the consumer base.


Saturday, February 23, 2013

March PF Topic

Here's an article describing the penalties the government can level against individuals who don't have health insurance.

This piece is from the Cato Institute in 2007, but offers help for the PRO side.

These items showed up when I searched for "health care mandate."

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Oak Ridge (Apr. 6) Is Using the March PF Topic!

Huzzah!  Here's the topic:

Resolved: The U.S. government should not require its citizens to have health insurance.

Monday, February 4, 2013

March 2013 PF Topic

Resolved: The U.S. government should not require its citizens to have health insurance.

I like this topic.  Unfortunately there aren't any tournaments for us to go during March.  High Schools take a break from hosting tournaments for us because March is busy for them.  Between the state tournament, spring break and NFL qualifiers, there really isn't a free weekend for high school debate programs to devote to a middle school tournament.

I'm hoping that I can convince Oak Ridge (April 6) to use the March topic and will keep you posted.

FYI - the other PF topic that could've been used for March was this: Resolved: That benefits of increasing involuntary commitment for individuals with serious mental illness outweighs the harms.

Monday, January 21, 2013

Feb. PF Topic Analysis II - "Interests of the U.S."

Eat your vegetables!  Go to bed on time!

When you're young your parents tell you these things because they're looking out for you.  A parent who didn't care how much soda you drank or what time you went to bed would be considered a pretty awful parent.  Even when people age, the concept of what's good for you isn't necessarily what you want to do is still very much alive.  Find time to work out!  Avoid fast-food!  Don't tell that person what you really think of them!  The things that are in our best interests often run contrary to our desires.  Doing those things that would be beneficial to us often require discipline and self-restraint.  We work out not because we enjoy making time for it, getting sweaty and waking up sore the next morning, but because we see the long-term value in the activity benefiting our interests - namely the interest of health.  We restrain ourselves from telling off certain people because it benefits our professional relationship and helps us develop tact.  The point is that good health, positive professional relationships and diplomacy are worth the sacrifice.

So when we're trying to asses whether the rise of China is beneficial to the interests of the U.S., it's important for the PRO to remember that what is good for someone (or some country) may not always be what is immediately preferable.  There are several different ways to measure the interests of the U.S. There are 3 which should really be looked at for this debate:

Economic
No country wants high national debt, inflation and a high unemployment rate, but the U.S. economy has suffered from these maladies.  China owns a little over a $1 debt of our $15 trillion debt.  In looking at how our economy is related to China's check out the trade deficit and how China manipulates its currency to keep its products cheap.

National Security
It's hard to separate The War on Terror from our National Security interests, but it's important to remember that we have other issues to deal with outside of terrorism.  China isn't endorsing or supporting Al-Qaeda but there are a couple of areas that merit attention.  One would be China's partnership with Iran.  Another would be China's expansion into Africa.

Foreign Affairs
Our global influence has been tarnished lately with the ascension of China the and downgrading of our credit rating.  It's no secret to the rest of the world that the U.S. was one of the first dominoes to fall in the global recession.  Our authority and sheer hegemony has been suspect with the inconclusive results of the campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the surging of militant Islam in Libya, Mali, Algeria and Egypt.  The bottom line is that U.S. is no longer viewed as the world's "Superman."  We've recently proven to be vulnerable abroad and have made some foreign policy blunders.

These are some VERY broad-strokes.  That means these are some VERY general areas to explore, this is not an exhaustive list of areas to utilize.  It's very likely that at Hastings and Olle the main PF competition will be internal; our teams against our teams.  So the more you diversify your case with solid arguments, the better prepared you'll be.  And your judges will appreciate hearing some different arguments.

A couple of links to get you started

Googling, Binging, Yahooing - whatever you want to call it - "Chinas impact on the U.S." brought up these websites:

This is on about.com which is usually suspect so check the sources.

This is from a CNN blog from a couple of years ago. And it's on CNN so it's dumbed down. That's right: CNN is for dummies.

And this is from The Heritage Society. The Heritage Society is very Conservative.

Enjoy.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Feb. PF Topic Analysis I

Resolved: On balance, the rise of China is beneficial to the interests of the United States.

Another proposition of fact...ugh.  And we have "On balance."  I want to set those aspects aside for now and just focus on framing the topic.

After WWII, the United States was more or less the only developed country standing.  Unless you lived in Pearl Harbor, your town was pretty much able shift from making war supplies to manufacturing goods to be consumed by a population that saw its men return from the war and start families.  Home construction shot up.  Jobs were created.  Our economy was pretty self-sufficient not just because it had the resources but because it HAD to be.  Who else was going to help?  Most of the developed countries in Europe were in shambles.  Japan had been decimated and cowed into submission.  And the United Kingdom was digging itself out of the Blitzkrieg and taking care of its own.

So what was happening in China?  What follows is highly generalized: The Soviet Union kicked Japan out of China.  With the Japanese out, China faced a power struggle between the communists and the faction representing the Republic.  The communists won and China became "The People's Republic of China."  The U.S. most definitely saw the rise of China's communism as a threat but were soon entangled in a different Asian country: Korea.  The ensuing Korean War pulled the U.S.'s attention away from China.

During the 1970's, the government "relaxed" a lot of its policies.  Despite the fact that the Chinese constitution provides for free speech, freedom of the press, etc. the government tightly regulates these rights.  But China recognized that truly communist governments don't usually have thriving economies.  Cuba. North Korea. Venezuela (I know - they're Socialists, but bear with me).  These countries do not have thriving economies.  So China adapted it's brand of communism to partner with free markets.  It's not that China's human rights record is much better than those other countries, but what China did pose was a threat in terms of its rapidly expanding population and the fact that it has nuclear weapons.  As a result, President Nixon opened trade with China as a way of keeping your friends close, but your enemies closer.  The idea was that China would be a viable trading partner the U.S. could benefit from.  Few people, if any, predicted that  China would wind up having the power in the relationship via owning our debt because our own economy would demand high government spending and decrease the value of our dollar.  Currently, China owns about $1.2 trillion of the U.S. debt.

The "rise of China" is a figurative rise.  Their economy, their hegemony, their military and their global influence have all risen from what was a borderline third world environment over the past sixty years.  The debate over whether or not China is a "developing nation" or "developed nation" is not relevant to this debate (this is my opinion).  The "rise" is not what's in question.  The question is whether or not it can benefit us or harm us.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

Who is Citizens United? Depends on who you ask...

So while researching the FEC is as painfully boring as waiting for a class to finish a standardized test, Citizens United is a little more interesting, mainly because of its partisan nature.

There are two things to examine:
1. What is CU's mission?
2. Who is David Bossie (CU's President and Chairman of the Board)

You don't have to do much researching to conclude that it's the Conservative's answer to Michael Moore.  For what it's worth, they both have imdb profiles:

Michael Moore's imdb profile
David Bossie's imdb profile

One look at Bossie's "headshot" on imdb and he looks like Salesman of the Month at your local car dealership.  Here is Citizens United homepage:

What CU is

And here is why people criticize them:

Liberals Hatin' on CU

It is worth noting that the criticism is partisan (Liberals hate them - Conservatives defend them).  And when you read the article you should probably do a quick search on the Koch Brothers, who they are linked to.

Or you could read this. You're welcome.

(Disclaimer: There are a handful of spelling/grammatical errors in the above article.  Apparently the desire to bash the Koch Brothers and CU overwhelmed the desire spell-check and proofread.)

The FEC: Six People You Meet and Could Care Less About

With the Federal Election Commission being involved in the January PF topic, I looked into what the FEC does and who's involved.  What I found was intriguing..said no one ever.  I hate to sound cynical and it's important for debaters to understand the Who, Why, etc. regarding the FEC, but beyond a basic understanding of what function it serves there's very little controversy.  Here's the link:

FEC

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Jan. PF Analysis

Resolved: On balance, the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission harms the election process.

Please make sure you understand how propositions of fact work before you read this.  You should read the  post a couple of posts back.  You did?  Awesome.  Let's continue.

"On balance" sometimes confuses people.  I think in all PF debates both sides concede that their opponents have some good arguments, but that OVERALL their own side is correct.  "On balance" simply makes sure you understand that you're going to HAVE to concede that your opponents arguments have some merit, but that your side OUTWEIGHS the other.  One way to think of it is that "On balance" is a synonym for "Overall."

Taking what you remember from propositions of fact, you can see that "the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission" is A, "harms" is the verb, and "the election process" is B.  A solid understanding of what the Supreme Court decision entails is important.  This is pretty objective since the Supreme Court offers opinions on both sides of the issue which outline why they individually ruled how they did.  What I think is a little more elusive to define is "the election process."  What is this process?  Is it the campaigning?  Is it the mudslinging?  Is it the actual voting and does that include the information that voters receive to deliberate on who they should vote for?  Keep in mind, this debate involves federal offices, not state or local offices.

One other aspect to keep in mind is that the overwhelming support for the decision came from Republicans, with the majority of Democrats (including Barack Obama) being very critical of the decision. Just puttin' that out there...

Once you have solid definitions for "A," "harms," and "B" you can move into arguments for PRO and CON.

PRO
If the election process is as simple as people making informed decisions on how they vote, then any propaganda out there that might mislead voters will taint their decisions.  Movies like Fahrenheit 9/11 and 2016: Obama's America are intended to sway voter opinion.  At the most, these movies should stir debate and force people to do their own research.  But few people have the time/discipline to do that and will just think "Michael Moore said..." or "The Obama movie said..." and go with that.  There's a huge difference between an ignorant electorate and a misinformed electorate and the latter is just as dangerous if not more dangerous than the former.  You want to show that the decision of the Supreme Court has and can continue to lead to a misinformed electorate, thus harming the electoral process.

Another avenue for the PRO to explore is the "equal time" issue.  As debaters, you definitely understand that both sides deserve equal time.  Rioting in your debate round would ensue if your judge screwed up your time and gave your opponents more time than they were supposed to receive (I know that's happened to some of you and you know how badly it stinks).  The same holds true for the supporters of the two political parties in the country.  One Super PAC has the resources that another doesn't and is therefore able to promote its agenda more effectively.  For more about equal time look at the first PF topic I ever tackled in my job as Lanier Debate coach: The Fairness Doctrine, Sept. 2007.

One last issue for PRO is idea that a corporation is not afforded the same rights as an individual.  When a company winds up poisoning people and they are successfully sued their penalty is to pay out settlements.  However, if an individual (through their own negligence) poisons people then they are going to jail.  The law makes a distinction between individuals and companies run by individuals.  But corporations are NOT individual citizens and therefore what rights do they have?  Do corporations have a right to free speech? What if there are films financed by corporations or non-profits with foreign ties and investments? 

CON
As much as PRO might be the majority opinion among debaters (at least that's my first impression) CON has some very good arguments to make.

First and foremost is that the decision of the court allows for more free speech.  These films, for example, don't commit slander (legal definition: slander n. oral defamation, in which someone tells one or more persons an untruth about another which untruth will harm the reputation of the person defamed)  In fact they are carefully orchestrated to go just far enough in encouraging the viewer make assumptions based on the facts that are presented in a certain way.  Moore's and D'Souza's films are criticized for not being true documentaries because they are made with a political agenda in mind.  However, a LOT of Hollywood films are produced with a political/social agenda in mind.  Are all film-makers bound by Feingold-McCain?  By restricting their release are you violating their free speech, not to mention free enterprise (not that documentary filmmakers are millionaires but they still need to eat).

Another point for the CON to utilize is the fact that this decision is in line with what a lot of media is able to do.  Days before an election, it's perfectly legal for a major/minor newspaper to editorialize about who they endorse for office.  It's almost an obligation.  How can that be okay, yet non-profit groups and corporations alike would be rendered silent if the decision was reversed?  Moreover, how much more harmful are journalistic endorsements of candidates than non-profit/corporate films? 

I realize I've given 3 PRO's and 2 CON's.  Sorry to those of you concerned with quantity over quality.  I feel the CON free speech point can probably be broken down into a couple of sub-points.  And with all topics and analysis I offer - Please do your own research.


Friday, December 28, 2012

Jan. PF link to Nats 2010 PF topic

Here's the topic for January, 2013: Resolved: On balance, the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission harms the election process.

And this was the topic for Nationals in 2010: Resolved: Current trends in American political dialogue compromise meaningful democratic deliberation.

One way to paraphrase the Nats 2010 topic: Partisan propaganda does harm to the democratic process.

A lot of PF topics get recycled and this, in my opinion, is one that has been recycled with the specification that we are not looking at current trends in general but specifically at CU v FEC, and the impact it has had on our electoral process (which happens to function within a democracy). 

I'm not stating that these topics are similar enough to find cases from June 2010 and run with them, BUT if you do some internet digging you can probably find some back-files from that topic that can help with the current topic.  Oh wait...I did that for you.


courtesy of Harrisburgh Debate



Thursday, December 27, 2012

Jan. PF Topic Analysis

Resolved: On balance, the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission harms the election process.

First off, it's been a while since we've seen an "On balance..." topic.   (April 2010 - Resolved: On balance, government employee labor unions have a positive impact on the United States.)  This is another proposition of fact (A has this impact on B).  I personally dislike these topics.  While we haven't had an "On balance" topic we've had A LOT of propositions of fact.  But before I go over that, let's take a quick trip through CU v FEC.

In June of 2004, controversial documentary filmmaker Michael Moore released a film titled Fahrenheit 9/11: The temperature where freedom burns (clever, huh?)  Moore is no friend of conservatives and this film focused on President Bush's activity before, during and after the attacks even going so far as to assert that 9/11 was an inside job. (These conspiracy theorists are referred to ironically as 'truthers.')  Whatever your opinion on the matter, what was clear was that Moore's goals with the film were to influence the upcoming 2004 election between President Bush and Senator John Kerry.  It apparently didn't work.

Citizens United is a non-profit conservative advocacy group.  They protested that the release of Fahrenheit 9/11 prior to the election violated the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (commonly known as the McCain–Feingold Act or "BCRA")  This act prohibited corporations and unions from using their general treasury to fund "electioneering communications" (broadcast advertisements mentioning a candidate) within 30 days before a primary or 60 days before a general election.  Citizens United's challenge of the film's release with the Federal Election Commission (FEC) was dismissed.  So CU's response was basically "Okay.  If liberals like Michael Moore can do it, we can, too."  So they released a film in early 2008 called Hillary: The Movie to be released on DirecTV.  This film was highly critical of then-Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton.  The advertisements for the film ran before the Democratic Primary, which caused the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to claim the film violated the boundaries set by BCRA.  Citizens United appealed the decision to the Supreme Court (which by this time had been restocked with Conservative leaning President Bush picks).  The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Citizens United.

A constitutional attorney would be helpful at this point as I've basically summed up what Wikipedia has  to offer on the subject (don't worry - I corroborated with other sources).  If you were able to follow the two previous paragraphs then you might look at the Supreme Court decision and conclude that they sort of had to rule in favor of CU and the airing of their conservative film since the FEC had allowed Michael Moore's liberal film.  Denying CU's appeal would lead people to think there was a partisan double standard - liberals can do this but conservatives can't.

Unfortunately, the Supreme Court has opened the door to all sorts of "propaganda."  Consider the film 2016: Obama's America.  This was released the year of Obama's re-election campaign and argues that President Obama wants to reduce significantly the U.S.'s influence within the world while increasing the influence of nations that he believes have suffered or been held back economically or militarily due to U.S. and Western domination.  Overall, it's a very negative portrayal of the President.  I haven't seen the film so I won't comment on it, but just like Fahrenheit 9/11, I'll assume it runs with some basic facts and then gives you a very biased picture of what the filmmaker believes is the "truth."  Thanks to the Supreme Court's decision regarding CU vs. FEC, Obama supporters had little recourse but to let the film be released.  Much like Fahrenheit 9/11, it apparently had little effect on the election.

This is really just the back-story.  As Shakespeare wrote, "What is past is prologue."  In future posts I'll go over the way to go about analyzing propositions of fact and some basic PRO and CON approaches.  As with all topics, I highly recommend you do some research on your own.  I've only provided the "children's dictionary" set-up.